Even as the Obama administration works to convince the American public that the Affordable Health Care Act is not the unmitigated failure that it obviously is, they are currently also working to build the next puzzle piece in the Obama legacy. Immigration reform. Or as many will see it, amnesty.
As even the most ardent supporters of the President are forced to admit that Obamacare has been a failure out of the gate, be it the ever-growing number of large companies that were exempted by the administration, right up to the failure to launch of the website, to the abysmal lack of interest by America’s young adults, the very people needed to make this scam work, we see the Obama administration working to shift the focus off of that failure onto immigration.
The question is, will the opposition handle the immigration reform battle any better than they did the battle against Obamacare?
There is no question that there is an ever-growing problem in the form of illegal immigrants moving into this country. But how to solve this problem?
As always it will be defined as a left v. right in the media, and of course the fringe elements on both sides of the political spectrum will happily play their roles.
We will have the hard left shouting about how the right is racist for not wanting to allow open borders, and the hard right will be shouting about how the illegals are stealing jobs and resources.
So who is right? Well as always, there is truth on both sides. The immigrants that come here do take jobs that could be filled by American citizens, and they do avail themselves of the ever-growing list of entitlement programs that are available to all who apply.
And on the other side, there is clearly racism embedded within much of the rhetoric of the hard right. Often the opposition to the immigrants is hidden beneath the call for constitutional justice, when in reality the opposition is simply the fear and loathing of a people who are different from ones own self.
I will leave the discussion of the left’s point of view to people who see themselves as being better suited to discuss, and defend that view. I, seeing myself as a conservative, will address the views, and the goals of the conservative movement and the Republican Party.
Anyone paying attention should see that Pres. Obama and the Democrats are building towards making immigration the next big campaign issue. They have pushed through Obamacare, and in doing so demonstrated the GOP’s inability to deal with a PR nightmare, that being the faction within the GOP that sees itself as being the face and the voice of the new GOP. This faction chose to use carnival sideshow barker tactics to gin up support for their fight against Obamacare, which in the end backfired, and caused more Americans to move away from the conservative message. It also allowed the President, and the Democrats to look reasonable, while implementing the single most radical change in the history of America.
So, will we see the same tactics again employed, to oppose the radical ideas of the Obama administration when it comes to immigration reform? I am afraid that yes we will. The radical faction within the GOP is obviously blind and deaf, if only they were mute, when it comes to political maneuvering. They are actually out there making the argument that losing by a close margin in the governor’s race in Virginia is somehow a victory. Do these people understand, that you don’t get to govern, if you don’t win?
In my view, the GOP must do a better job of messaging on all issues, and especially on immigration. Right now the GOP is seen as race haters, that we are for breaking up families, and are against people seeking the American dream. We have allowed the media to paint us in this manner, in large part, by allowing race haters to be the loudest voices on this issue from the right.
In my opinion the GOP should take a position of prioritizing the problems facing the nation on the issue of immigration.
Instead of the sweeping all or nothing, “we have to pass it before we will know what is in it”, mentality that lead us into the fiasco of Obamacare, the GOP should be pushing for calmer heads this time. We should be talking about one piece of the puzzle at a time. In my view, the most important and pressing factor on immigration reform is border security.
We cannot talk about how to create a path to citizenship for those already here, until we staunch the flow of immigrants that simply walk into the country over our southern border. However, border security is not a simple case of fences and guards, we must also remove the benefits of coming here illegally. Controlling the influx of immigrants that come here outside the laws of this nation is a multi-pronged issue.
The number one issue of immigration reform is stopping, or at least slowing, the number of immigrant coming into the country illegally, or as undocumented, if that feels better for you. To do this, we will need more border guards, we will need more fences, we will need laws that punish employers who hire people without documentation of citizenship, or other forms of legal status that allows them to be a positive contribution to the nation, rather than a negative drain on the infrastructure.
Until America has at least gotten a reasonable hand hold on this problem, then there is no reason to address the other issues of immigration, such as a path to citizenship for those already here.
This does not mean that we should simply turn a blind eye towards those who managed to get in under the radar. If an immigrant breaks the laws of this nation, then they should be punished, if they are a non-citizen, then they should be deported. If we are to be a nation of laws, then those laws must be enforced equally.
What I expect to see on immigration reform from the left is an all out offensive to pass reform that creates a path to citizenship, and bestows all of the benefits of citizenship, without any real focus on border security.
What I would hope to see from the right is a push to secure the borders, and to sanctify the act of becoming a citizen of this nation, beyond simply being able to avoid detection.
This brings me to messaging. In the past the right in general, and the GOP specifically have been demonized for their position on immigration. This has not been hard to do considering some of the rhetoric coming from the right, be it talk radio, or other organizations that see themselves as patriot guards of all things America.
Too often this rhetoric, while replete with words like, “liberty, justice, constitutional, patriotism”, is at best window-dressing for the underlying feelings of those most passionate about this issue. When one listens carefully, one will also hear words like, “these people, those people, Mexicans”, and in some cases even more overtly racist statements.
We on the right must first realize and address the fact that many who oppose immigration reform do so simply out of fear of things unknown, or different from themselves. They oppose all reform because they see any immigrant as being a negative influence on their view of what it means to be an American, which considering our history is beyond ironic.
If the right, and the GOP, are to change the views held of our stance on immigration, then we must first recognize that it is not the immigrants themselves that we should be opposing. It is our government, and coextensively, our own failure to address this societal problem. We must shift the focus from the individual immigrant, to the cause of this problem, which is a lack of enforcement of existing laws on the part of our federal government.
We should not however allow ourselves to be seen as opposing people who wish only to come here to share in the American dream of Liberty and prosperity while insisting that they do so legally. In most cases these are hard-working family oriented people, not unlike anyone of us who were born of this nation. They work so as to support their families, to raise their children to live a better life then they have had themselves. They seek to buy homes, to start businesses, to be members of a community. Unfortunately they have begun this journey in a way that forces them to live within closed self-contained communities, which prohibits them from becoming members of the larger national community. This only adds to the fear and mistrust of the American citizens that see them as invaders.
This issue has morphed from being one of national security, into simply a political football. It is no longer about the sovereignty of America’s borders, but is painted as being solely about the people seeking to enter this nation. The left shares as much fault in this as does the right. The left has played on the emotions of people by portraying this as an issue of purely the individual impact of the people coming here, the right has played on the emotions and fears of people who see the immigrants as invaders.
When really the issue is about the rule of law, and the equal enforcement of those laws, and about the impact upon the nation as a whole. I would encourage my fellow conservatives to focus not on the immigrants themselves, but to focus on the failure of the government to do that which it is charged with, upholding the principles and values, and laws of this nation.
Recent Comments